How accurate is Death by Lightning?
Death by Lightning begins by posing a simple question: “Who is Charles Guiteau?” This question sets the tone for Netflix’s new historical mini-series, which blends political thriller elements with tragedy, while maintaining a strong focus on historical truth.
The series raises curiosity about how much of the Netflix portrayal aligns with actual American history. The answer is that much of it is rooted in fact. Although some artistic liberties are taken to enhance the viewing experience, Death by Lightning remains remarkably faithful to the real story of President James Garfield’s rise and tragic demise.
“Death by Lightning does a remarkable job of staying as faithful as it can to the real story of President James Garfield’s rise and shocking fall.”
Some narrative choices and adjusted timelines give the story a cinematic flair that may seem almost unreal. In the series, James Garfield, played by Michael Shannon, is shown as a modest man who never sought the presidency. The opening scene depicts him building a table, symbolizing his practical, hardworking nature rather than a political ambition—an accurate reflection of the historical Garfield.
“Garfield was, in fact, happier on his Ohio farm than he was in Washington.”
Summary
Death by Lightning effectively balances dramatic storytelling with historical accuracy, offering a compelling yet largely truthful glimpse into President James Garfield’s life and assassination.