Josh Hutcherson’s New HBO Show Divides Critics and Viewers
The HBO series I Love LA premiered on November 2 and has sparked mixed reactions among audiences and critics alike, according to Rotten Tomatoes. Created by Rachel Sennott, the comedy centers on a close-knit group of friends reuniting after years apart, highlighting how their experiences have transformed them.
Critical Reception
Critics have responded very positively to I Love LA, awarding the show an 81% Certified Fresh rating based on 32 reviews. Many praise its absurdist humor tailored to Gen Z sensibilities. Sam Adams of Slate notes the writing sharpens as the series progresses, appreciating its character development. Chris Vognar from the Boston Globe highlights how the show makes its often unlikable protagonists relatable and sympathetic.
Audience Reaction
Viewers, however, remain divided, with the audience score standing at 59% from fewer than 50 ratings. Some applaud the show’s comedic style and modern appeal to young adults, but others criticize its clichéd portrayal of Los Angeles and feel it falls short in delivering authentic emotional moments.
According to Sam Adams, the show’s “writing gets sharper” through its episodes while maintaining strong character portrayals.
Chris Vognar appreciates how the series “makes its unlikable protagonists sympathetic.”
Summary
I Love LA has succeeded critically with sharp writing and character depth, but its reception among viewers is more mixed due to perceived clichés and uneven emotional impact.
Author’s note: The show highlights creative risks that resonate well with critics but divide viewers, revealing contrasting expectations for contemporary comedy.