Has Anthony Stolarz been good enough for the Leafs?

Has Anthony Stolarz Been Good Enough for the Leafs?

The Toronto Maple Leafs have had a mixed start to the season following their division-winning campaign last year. One of the team's biggest advantages in the past was its reliable goaltending.

Before this season began, general manager Brad Treliving signed Anthony Stolarz to a four-year contract worth an average annual value of $3.75 million. The signing looked strong at the time, especially after Stolarz’s previous season where he recorded a .926 save percentage over 34 games.

Goaltending Under Pressure

However, Stolarz’s performance this season has been the subject of debate. A key factor influencing his results has been the Leafs' defensive struggles. Toronto’s defensive core has allowed far too many high-danger opportunities, making life difficult for any goaltender.

“Stolarz has faced the ninth most high danger shots out of any goalie in the league.”

Such pressure has contributed to Toronto allowing the seventh-most goals in the NHL this season. Currently, Stolarz holds a .895 save percentage, a noticeable drop from his previous performance. The data also shows that he has a -0.85 goals saved above average (GSAA), ranking him 43rd among NHL goalies.

Statistical Decline and Impact

While Stolarz’s numbers have dipped, much of that decline can be attributed to the defensive breakdowns in front of him. Still, compared to last season, more high-quality chances appear to be getting through, and that has affected his confidence and results.

The Leafs’ success moving forward may depend on whether both Stolarz and the defensive unit can find a more stable rhythm together.

Author’s summary: Stolarz’s season has been uneven, driven more by Toronto’s defensive lapses than by his own regression, but improving his and the team’s stability remains essential for playoff hopes.

Editor In Leaf — 2025-11-08