Every Kevin Costner Western Movie, Ranked Worst to Best

Kevin Costner is synonymous with the Western genre, delivering memorable performances in numerous classics and lesser-known titles alike. This ranking explores his Western movies from the least acclaimed to the most celebrated, highlighting standout roles and distinct qualities that define his impact on the genre.

1. The Postman (1997)

Often criticized and considered one of Costner's weakest Westerns, The Postman attempts to blend post-apocalyptic storytelling with classic Western themes but falls short in pacing and narrative cohesion. Despite its shortcomings, it showcases Costner's ambition to reinvent the genre.

2. Yellowstone (2023, TV Series)

Though technically not a movie, Yellowstone represents the modern Western landscape driven by Costner’s compelling portrayal of John Dutton, a powerful ranch owner. The show’s popularity reinvigorated interest in Western stories with contemporary relevance.

3. Dragonfly (1996)

While primarily a supernatural thriller, elements of Western motifs surface through Costner’s character’s rugged determination, though it remains a departure from traditional Western storytelling.

4. Wyatt Earp (1994)

Wyatt Earp attempts to offer a biographical glimpse of the famous lawman but has been criticized for its slow pace and length. Costner’s dedication to the role reflects his deep connection to Western history, even if the film divides audiences.

5. Open Range (2003)

Praised for its authenticity and compelling depiction of the open plains, Open Range stands out as a modern Western classic. Costner’s role as a stoic cattleman highlights themes of justice and freedom. The film’s strong direction and naturalistic cinematography earned it critical acclaim.

6. Dances with Wolves (1990)

This landmark film cemented Costner's status in Hollywood and the Western genre. Winning seven Academy Awards, including Best Picture and Best Director, the story explores the relationship between a Union soldier and the Lakota Sioux tribe with sensitivity and depth. It remains a touchstone for Western storytelling.

Kevin Costner's Western filmography reveals his passion for the genre through varied roles that range from ambitious experiments to timeless classics, showcasing his evolution as an actor and filmmaker in Western cinema.

FandomWire — 2025-11-29