Even though Amonsen has thoroughly prepared and studied the role of Sean Reagan to closely resemble his predecessor, his casting has sparked backlash from some fans.
Some viewers strongly identified with the previous actor Terraciano, leading to emotional responses over the change. Amonsen acknowledges this reaction but remains committed to honoring the character and continuing the legacy with respect.
“I understand why people feel protective of the role and the previous portrayal,” Amonsen said. “I’ve worked hard to keep the essence of Sean Reagan alive.”
Despite criticism, Amonsen brings his own energy and dedication to the character, aiming to respect the show’s history while making the role his own.
This highlights how passionate fans can be about character continuity, but also how new actors must balance honoring the past with bringing fresh life to their roles.